Tuesday, 25 February 2025

Food for Spain? Propaganda, civil society, and the humanitarian debate in Oxford during the Spanish Civil War

On 25 February 2025, the ESC hosted a seminar examining the role of food, humanitarianism, and political mobilisation in the Spanish Civil War. The discussion centred on the research of Ainhoa Campos Posada, St Antony's Ramón Areces Visiting Fellow. Her work focuses on the civilian experience of the civil war, and explores how food was weaponised, how the conflict shaped British attitudes, and how Oxford became a hub for supporting Republican Spain.

The Spanish Civil War, fought between 1936 and 1939, was a deeply polarising conflict between the Nationalists and Republicans. Beyond its military aspects, food became a tool of war, used to inflict damage as effectively as arms. In agricultural regions, particularly in conservative strongholds, controlling food production and distribution was crucial. The Republicans relied on supply lines to sustain both soldiers and civilians, encapsulated in the phrase, “tanto un arado como una ametralladora” – a plough is as important as a machine gun. Food shortages and targeted disruptions of supply routes played a decisive role in the war’s outcome.

British attitudes towards the Spanish Civil War were shaped by the government’s official non-interventionist stance. While the Labour Party also promoted non-intervention, it expressed empathy for the Republican cause. Within British society, especially in academic and intellectual circles, the war ignited intense debates and spurred efforts to aid Republican Spain. Oxford, with its politically engaged student body and vibrant intellectual culture, became a key centre of mobilisation. The war left a lasting imprint on the city, with university students and local residents actively involved in campaigns.

Tuesday, 18 February 2025

Europe and Middle Powers: EU's relations with India, Brazil and Turkey

The seminar, held on February 18, 2025, at the European Studies Centre at Oxford University, brought together experts to discuss how non-European actors and the “middle powers” – India, Brazil, and Turkey – fit into the evolving new global order. Chaired by Dr Dimitar Bechev, Director of the Dahrendorf Programme at the European Studies Centre, the panel featured Dr Kira Huju, Fellow in International Relations at the London School of Economics and Political Science, Rodrigo Fracalossi de Moraes, Researcher on Public Policies and International Relations at the Department of International Development at Oxford University, and Galip Dalay, Senior Consulting Fellow at Chatham House.

The discussion began with a reflection on the importance of moving away from a Eurocentric viewpoint. The speakers examined how historical legacies, power dynamics, and past relationships continue to shape the role of non-European countries in global affairs. There was a strong emphasis on understanding how different regions engage with global institutions and major powers while also navigating their own internal political landscapes.

Huju, a former Oxford student and an expert on India, highlighted two key signals in the evolving relationship between the European Union and India. The first was the EU’s increasing eagerness to deepen ties with India, reflecting a shift in strategic priorities. The second was an implicit acknowledgment that the EU has significantly underperformed in its engagement with India, leaving much of the relationship’s potential unexplored. While the EU aspires to establish itself as a geopolitical player in the Indo-Pacific, this effort is largely confined to individual member states, such as France, which has prioritised defence cooperation with India. However, these national efforts do not necessarily translate into a coherent EU-wide approach.

Monday, 17 February 2025

The new European Parliament and European Commission: Who won the 2024 power-play in Brussels?

On February 11, 2025, the European Studies Centre at University of Oxford hosted an insightful seminar featuring Klaus Welle, former Secretary General of the European Parliament, and Anthony Teasdale, visiting professor in Practice at the European Institute of the London School of Economics. The event, chaired by Catherine Briddick, Andrew W Mellon Associate Professor of International Human Rights and Refugee Law at St. Antony’s College, Oxford University, focused on the shifting power dynamics in Brussels following the 2024 European elections, highlighting governance challenges, parliamentary realignments, and the future direction of European integration.

Klaus Welle opened the discussion by emphasising the unique structure of the European Parliament. Unlike national systems where power is fused within a parliamentary majority, the European Union (EU) operates through a diffusion of power. This federal-style system ensures that no single party dominates; instead, the EU is governed by a complex web of institutions—the Commission, the Parliament, and the Council—where alliances are essential to achieving legislative goals.

A key takeaway from Welle’s remarks was the changing composition of the European Parliament. The 2024 elections resulted in a divided assembly, with one-third of members aligned with left-wing parties, a strong centrist faction, and a growing presence of right-wing representatives. The steady rise of right-wing populist parties across member states, such as Le Pen’s National Rally in France and the Alternative for Germany (AfD), mirrors the broader European political landscape. Notably, the so-called “progressive majority” that had characterised the previous Parliament has now disappeared, with left-leaning parties falling below the 45% threshold necessary to form a stable coalition.

Monday, 10 February 2025

Traumerland: How Poland's WWII past shapes its collective mentality and politics today

Poland's history is deeply marked by the trauma of World War II, a period that continues to influence the nation's collective mentality and political landscape. The concept of "war trauma" is central to understanding the psychological and social dynamics in Poland today. On February 4, 2025 European Studies Centre hosted a seminar on this topic featuring Michał Bilewicz, Associate Professor of Psychology at the University of Warsaw, and was chaired by Timothy Garton Ash, Professor of European Studies at the University of Oxford. It looks into the lasting effects of this trauma, exploring how it manifests in contemporary Polish society, politics, and attitudes toward historical events.

The trauma of World War II left an indelible mark on Poland, not just in terms of physical destruction but also in the psychological scars it inflicted on the population. Stefan Baley, a psychologist, observed the profound changes in the minds of young people after the war. He described them as "suspicious, irritable, anxious, and mistrusting of institutions," with a pervasive sense of injustice. This generation, traumatised by the war, developed a mentality of breaking norms and rules, often feeling that everything was a lie. This "war complex" has been passed down through generations, influencing how Poles react to crises and perceive the world around them.

The trauma of WWII didn't end with the war; it lingered, manifesting in symptoms akin to Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). Anxiety, flashbacks, and hypervigilance became common among those who lived through the war. This trauma was also transmitted to subsequent generations, who, while not directly experiencing the war, inherited the psychological scars of their ancestors. This phenomenon, known as secondary traumatic stress, means that younger generations are more reactive to events that echo the traumas experienced by their elders.

Monday, 27 January 2025

EU-China Relations – Can cooperation and competition coexist?

The relationship between the European Union (EU) and China is one of the most intricate and consequential in today’s global landscape. 

On January 21, 2025, the European Studies Centre hosted a seminar featuring Dr Lucie Qian Xia, Lecturer at the Department of Politics and International Relations, and Dr Dimitar Bechev, Lecturer at the Oxford School of Global and Area Studies, University of Oxford. The discussion was chaired by Othon Anastasakis, Director of the European Studies Centre. The seminar explored the historical, theoretical, and contemporary dimensions of EU-China relations, offering valuable insights into how these two major powers navigate their shared interests and diverging priorities.

EU-China relations: A historical perspective

The roots of EU-China relations date back to 1975, during the height of the Cold War. Xia emphasized that this relationship has always been shaped by a network of institutions, despite the presence of opposing forces. Over the decades, it has evolved into a multifaceted dynamic, as encapsulated by the European Council’s 2019 strategic outlook, which frames China as simultaneously a partner, competitor, and systemic rival. This tripartite characterization reflects the inherent complexity that defines EU-China relations.

China, for its part, has consistently viewed the EU as a major strategic partner, as evidenced by its policy papers in 2003, 2014, and 2018. However, a significant gap in perception persists. While China’s rapid economic rise—driven by Deng Xiaoping’s “reform and opening” policies—has reshaped the global economic order, the EU has struggled to reconcile its economic interdependence with China with growing concerns over China’s geopolitical ambitions. This tension lies at the heart of EU-China relations.

Monday, 9 December 2024

Russia's war against Ukraine: Consequences for South East Europe

On 3 December 2024, the European Studies Centre hosted a compelling seminar on the impact of Russia's ongoing war against Ukraine on Southeast Europe. The discussion featured a distinguished panel, including Julie Newton, Research Fellow at St Antony’s College, Oxford; Maxim Samorukov, Fellow at the Carnegie Russia Eurasia Centre; Kyril Drezov, Lecturer in Politics at Keele University; and Vuk Vuksanovic, Senior Researcher at the Belgrade Centre for Security Policy. The event was chaired by Othon Anastasakis, Director of the European Studies Centre and Southeast European Studies at the University of Oxford. The seminar delved into the far-reaching consequences of Russia's geopolitical strategies on energy security, political alliances, and regional stability in the Balkans and Southeast Europe.

Context
Julie Newton opened the seminar by contextualising Southeast Europe’s pivotal role in Russia’s broader confrontation with the West. She described the region as a "grey zone" in European security—a strategic area where external interventions by Russia and the West remain likely. This zone is crucial for Russia, as it seeks to weaken Western cohesion while maintaining influence through populist and illiberal allies in countries like Serbia and Hungary. At the same time, Southeast Europe presents challenges for the West, given its vulnerabilities in governance and susceptibility to societal frustration, which can fuel populism and external manipulation.

Newton identified Russia’s medium-term goals, including neutralising threats from Ukraine, reshaping European security to counter NATO, and shifting the global balance of power away from Western dominance toward a Russia-China-led alternative. Southeast Europe, she argued, will continue to serve as a key battleground in this broader geopolitical conflict.

Monday, 2 December 2024

The New Politics of Poland

Jarosław Kuisz’s recent seminar at the European Studies Centre offered a compelling and timely exploration of Poland’s evolving political identity, based on his new book The New Politics of Poland. Drawing on his background as a legal scholar, editor-in-chief of Kultura Liberalna, and seasoned commentator on Polish and European affairs, Kuisz presented an argument centred around the concept of “post-traumatic sovereignty”. This term, he explained, captures how the repeated historical loss of statehood continues to shape political life in Poland today—often in ways that transcend rational policymaking.

Poland’s modern trajectory is striking: from communist domination to democratic transition, followed by a period of democratic backsliding, and more recently, renewed efforts at re-democratisation since the 2023 elections. But for Kuisz, these political shifts cannot be understood in isolation from deeper historical legacies. Drawing on historical and cultural analysis, he argued that Polish politics is still haunted by the experience of being “wiped off the map”—first in the 18th-century partitions, again during the Second World War, and later through Soviet domination. This sense of impermanence and vulnerability, passed down through education, family memory, and literature, forms what he calls a "sovereignty trauma."

Kuisz traced how this trauma has been reactivated in recent decades, not only in relation to Russia, but also to the European Union. For many Poles, he argued, the EU was originally seen as a means of securing sovereignty—“escaping the trap of history”—but later came to be viewed, by parts of the political class, as a potential threat. During the Law and Justice government’s eight-year rule, this perspective was increasingly weaponised. Brussels was portrayed as a new Moscow, and sovereignty became a rallying cry not only against Russian authoritarianism, but also against perceived Western overreach.